The honest view from inside technical leadership
Analysis

Engineering leadership

Independent reporting on the decisions, costs and contracts that shape how engineering organizations build with AI.

Security · News

Meta Fined €805 Million in Italy Because Facebook Reached Phone Galleries Through One Bundled Permission

Italy’s data protection authority says a single app-wide photo permission could not double as consent for a gallery suggestion feature. Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask separately, and says it will appeal.

Line-art illustration of a smartphone photo gallery grid with a single key unlocking every tile, representing the €805 million Meta fine in Italy over Facebook gallery access

Meta was fined €805 million in Italy on 14 November 2026 because the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and their metadata in users’ phone galleries without specific consent, according to Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante. The authority found that one app-wide permission, granted after a vague notice, also switched on a gallery suggestion feature that was active by default.

Meta Was Fined €805 Million for a Facebook Gallery Feature Running Since 2023

The Garante’s decision targets Meta Platforms Ireland Limited and a feature called “Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook,” which has been available since 2023. While someone scrolls Facebook, the feature offers photos and videos from their phone’s gallery as ideas for new posts. The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre and drew on a technical analysis by the authority’s own staff. The fine equals about 0.47 percent of the Meta group’s worldwide revenue, the Garante says. BBC News reporter George Wright noted that it is among the largest penalties an Italian authority has imposed on a tech company.

One App-Wide Permission Unlocked Several Features at Once

The Garante found that Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission covering the whole app and several features with different purposes. The notice shown before that request asked users to enable other features, which the authority says gave no signal that gallery suggestions were included. The suggestion feature was also preset to on. Once fully granted, the Garante says, such a permission lets the app read the device’s entire photo archive on a continuing basis, and neither the user nor the regulator can check which information is actually used. Meta told the BBC it strongly disagrees, calling it a “straightforward feature which helps people post photos and videos to Facebook.” The company says people must grant permission on their device and can change it at any time.

Italy’s Regulator Applied ePrivacy Rules That Bypass the Irish One-Stop Shop

The Garante based the decision on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive and treats a smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere. Under that rule, any access to information stored on the device needs free and informed consent, whether or not the data leaves the phone and whether or not anyone is harmed. Meta argued that Ireland’s regulator, its lead authority under the GDPR, should handle the case. The Garante rejected that argument because the ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism. The authority also says the case did not examine whether the content was used to train AI, which Meta denies, and that it may separately review a feature launched in 2026 that processes gallery content in the cloud.

Meta Has 60 Days to Switch the Gallery Feature Off by Default

The Garante ordered Meta to ask for consent through a separate request specific to the feature, explaining what it does, that it reads the gallery and how to turn it off. The feature must stay off by default, including for users who already granted access. If Meta misses the 60-day deadline, the feature cannot run for anyone without valid consent. Meta must report its first steps within 30 days and its completed measures within 90. In setting the amount, the authority weighed about 20 million affected Android users in Italy, a violation still ongoing for people who have not updated the app, a 2019 decision against the company and what it called limited cooperation. It counted Meta’s post-complaint changes in mitigation, while calling them late and limited to users who update. Meta told the BBC it plans to appeal.

Why This Matters for Engineering Leadership

The Garante treated a bundled operating system permission as insufficient consent for a feature that used it, and it fined Meta on that basis alone, without any finding about data transfer or harm. Under the Garante’s reading, each new use of on-device data needs its own consent prompt, its own plain explanation and an off-by-default starting state, including for users who granted the permission years earlier. Engineering leaders should keep a register that maps every feature to the device permissions it reads and the consent record behind each one. Ship new features that read device storage behind a per-feature consent flag that defaults to off. Make sure consent can be revoked per feature server-side, because the Garante found the violation continuing for users who had not updated the app. And log which features actually read device data, since the regulator’s complaint was that nobody could verify what a full gallery permission was used for.

FAQ

Why did Italy fine Meta €805 million?

Italy’s Garante found that the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and metadata in users’ phone galleries without specific consent and without properly informing them.

Which Facebook feature does the fine cover?

It covers “Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook,” available since 2023, which suggests photos and videos from the phone gallery as ideas for posts.

What must Meta change in Italy?

Within 60 days Meta must ask for consent through a separate, specific request and keep the feature off by default, including for people who already granted gallery access.

Is the fine about Meta training AI on users’ photos?

No. The Garante says the case did not cover AI training, which Meta denies, and that it may separately assess a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud.

Why did Italy act instead of Ireland’s regulator?

The Garante rejected Meta’s argument that the Irish authority had jurisdiction, because the ePrivacy rules it applied have no one-stop-shop mechanism.

Will Meta appeal the Italian fine?

Yes. A Meta spokesperson told the BBC the company plans to appeal and disagrees with the regulator’s reading of the facts, the law and the size of the fine.

Source: Italy fines Meta €805m over accessing users’ photos by George Wright, BBC News, November 14, 2026. Primary source: Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro, Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, November 14, 2026.

Read more news & analysis