The honest view from inside technical leadership
Analysis

Leadership

Field notes on how engineering leaders keep control of systems as AI changes how software gets built.

Leadership · News

UPS Self-Tests on Synchronized Clocks Are Causing a One-Minute Grid Frequency Oscillation on Five Continents

Researchers at Forschungszentrum Jülich and their partners traced a 60-second pulse in grid frequency to battery self-tests that fire on the same clock tick in device after device. The fix they propose is one software teams already know: add randomness to the schedule.

Line-art illustration of a clock linked by dashed lines to three UPS units above a grid frequency trace with repeating dips, representing UPS self-tests causing a one-minute grid frequency oscillation

A dip in grid frequency that recurs exactly once a minute on five continents comes from uninterruptible power supplies and grid batteries running self-tests on clocks synchronized to the same second, according to a study published in Nature Energy on October 30, 2026. Each of those UPS self-tests draws a small pulse of power, and the pulses add up across a grid because thousands of devices share one time source. The study’s senior author is Dirk Witthaut of Forschungszentrum Jülich in Germany, and its co-authors include researchers from RWTH Aachen University, the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and the transmission operator TenneT.

Grid Frequency on Five Continents Shows the Same One-Minute Pattern

The researchers ran a Fourier analysis of frequency data from 12 power grids and found a narrow spectral peak at exactly one minute in every one of them. The grids range in size from about 400,000 customers in Iceland to more than 400 million in the Continental European synchronous area. The signal is strongest in the large interconnected systems of Europe, North America and Australia, and it is still clearly visible in Malaysia, South Korea, South Africa, Mallorca, Ireland and Iceland. The authors write that a peak this narrow points to a precisely timed process that has stayed stable over several years. Earlier research had linked oscillations near one minute to resonance in hydropower turbine control systems. TechCrunch’s Tim De Chant reported that TenneT Germany brought the puzzle to Witthaut, and that the team first modeled a hydropower control system on the Scandinavian grid. Resonance could produce a one-minute peak, but it could not explain a pulse that kept arriving every 60 seconds without fading or drifting. The team concluded that something was keeping time.

UPS Self-Tests on the Jülich Campus Produced the Same Minute-by-Minute Peaks

To find the clock, the team installed more than 80 power quality meters across the Jülich research campus. At the battery terminals of one UPS, the meters recorded narrow current peaks every minute. The manufacturer confirmed to the researchers that the peaks were periodic self-tests run by the battery energy management system, and the paper notes that similar minute-scale diagnostic routines are documented for other commercial UPS systems. The researchers traced the resulting power pattern through two transformers and a bus bar up to the campus connection with the public 110-kilovolt grid. UPS systems in two buildings showed steady demand peaks just after the start of each minute throughout the measurement period, from March 24 to July 3, 2024, while a third building’s UPS, from a different manufacturer, showed a pattern that drifted. Clock synchronization is what turns one device’s small draw into a grid-wide signal. These systems commonly set their clocks with the Network Time Protocol, which aligns them to Coordinated Universal Time. When the team disabled NTP on that third building’s UPS, its pattern drifted slowly from week to week. With NTP enabled, the pattern was pulled back into alignment every night at midnight UTC. For scale, the paper estimates that a 3 millihertz swing in the Continental European grid corresponds to a coherent power variation of about 80 megawatts.

Ireland’s Data Center Growth Coincided With a Fourfold Rise in the Frequency Dip

The size of the one-minute dip has grown fastest where battery-backed load has grown fastest. Data centers reached about 18% of Ireland’s national electricity demand in 2022, according to the paper, and between 2016 and 2021 the minute-scale frequency drop on the Irish grid rose from about 3 mHz to 12 mHz. More recent individual drops have exceeded 20 mHz. The authors write that when such a drop lands on top of a larger frequency excursion, it can bring the system close to the limits of its target operating range. The pattern already has a measurable cost. In the Scandinavian grid, amplitudes regularly exceeded 10 mHz and contributed to wear on the hydropower turbines that provide primary frequency control. Scandinavian transmission operators responded by tightening the qualification tests for frequency containment reserves, and amplitudes above 10 mHz were no longer observed in 2025. The authors point out that this kind of fix dampens the grid’s response and leaves the source untouched. They also found periodic power signatures in a smart baking oven and in Raspberry Pi clusters, at one-minute and 30-second periods.

Randomized Scheduling Fixes the Root Cause, and One Manufacturer Has Shipped a Partial Patch

The study recommends that clocked routines in energy devices stop making simultaneous power adjustments, using randomized scheduling, adaptive offsets, or event-driven execution in place of strictly time-driven timers. For utility-scale batteries and UPS systems, the authors write, this is technically feasible because software updates can be deployed centrally. After the researchers contacted the manufacturer of the Jülich UPS, it issued an update that removed the strict periodicity of the current peaks in one battery block. Self-tests still occur at discrete times, so the authors describe the root cause as only partly resolved. They expect household devices to be harder, because software updates and control standards for consumer IoT products are far less coordinated than for utility equipment.

Why This Matters for Engineering Leadership

Distributed systems engineers have a name for this failure: the thundering herd. A job scheduled for the top of every minute on thousands of machines hits a shared dependency at the same instant, and the standard remedy is jitter. The Jülich study shows the same failure in a physical system, built out of firmware decisions that each look sensible on their own. Run a self-test every minute. Keep the clock accurate. No single device did anything wrong, and the fault appeared only in aggregate, across several manufacturers, in a grid none of them operate. Three practical steps follow for engineering leaders. Audit fleet-wide periodic work, such as health checks, cache refreshes, telemetry flushes, certificate renewals and backups, for alignment to wall-clock boundaries, and make randomized offsets the default in your scheduling libraries. Treat accurate time sync as a coupling mechanism in your threat models and capacity plans, since it is precisely what makes independent devices act in lockstep. If your organization runs data centers or buys colocation, ask your UPS and battery vendors how their self-test schedules are set and whether they randomize them. The Jülich team got one manufacturer to change its firmware by asking.

FAQ

What causes the one-minute oscillation in grid frequency?

A Nature Energy study attributes it to clock-synchronized control software in uninterruptible power supplies and battery storage systems. Their periodic self-tests draw small power pulses that coincide across many devices.

Which power grids show the one-minute frequency pattern?

All 12 grids the researchers analyzed show it, across five continents. They range from Iceland, with about 400,000 customers, to the Continental European grid, with more than 400 million.

How much has the one-minute frequency dip grown in Ireland?

The study reports that the dip on the Irish grid rose from about 3 mHz in 2016 to 12 mHz in 2021, and some recent drops exceeded 20 mHz. Data centers made up about 18% of Irish electricity demand in 2022.

Is the one-minute grid oscillation dangerous?

The authors say large drops, added to bigger frequency swings, can push a grid close to the limits of its target operating range. In Scandinavia the pattern contributed to wear on hydropower turbines and led operators to tighten requirements.

How can UPS and battery manufacturers fix the problem?

The study recommends randomized scheduling, adaptive offsets or event-driven routines in place of strictly clock-timed ones. One manufacturer has already shipped an update that partly removed the periodicity in its UPS.

What does the UPS study mean for software engineering teams?

Periodic jobs aligned to a shared, accurate clock behave as one large synchronized load. Adding randomized jitter to fleet-wide schedules spreads that load out.

Source: Coordinated disturbances haunt grids worldwide. Here’s how researchers solved the mystery. by Tim De Chant, TechCrunch, November 8, 2026. Primary source: Hartmann et al., One-minute frequency disturbances from unintended synchronization in cyber–physical power systems, Nature Energy (October 30, 2026).

Read more news & analysis